Texas Fugitive Wanted Since Two Thousand One Is Arrested in Flagstaff After Police Say He Lived for Years Under an Alias
FLAGSTAFF, AZ — A man wanted in Texas since 2001 was arrested in Flagstaff this week, ending a search that had stretched on for 25 years, according to police.
Authorities say 61-year-old Thomas Crumpler was taken into custody on Nov. 19 on a Lubbock County warrant accusing him of indecency with a child. Police say he had been living in northern Arizona under an assumed name while investigators continued to follow the case.
Flagstaff police announced the arrest Thursday and said the case moved forward after a new lead connected Crumpler to family ties in Ohio and helped investigators identify his alias.
How investigators traced the long-running case to northern Arizona
Police said the breakthrough began when U.S. Marshals Task Force members in Lubbock developed a lead involving family connections in Ohio. That information was passed to the Southern Ohio Fugitive Apprehension Strike Team on Nov. 17.
A deputy U.S. marshal with the agency’s Cold and Complex Case Group then linked Crumpler to the alias John Paul McGregor and shared that information with investigators in Arizona and Texas, Flagstaff police said.
By early Nov. 19, investigators contacted Crumpler while he was using the assumed name John McGregor. Police said they then arrested him on the outstanding felony warrant from Texas.
Police say Crumpler had been living under an assumed name for about 25 years
Authorities say Crumpler had remained in Flagstaff for roughly a quarter of a century while avoiding capture. The long gap between the warrant and the arrest did not change the seriousness of the case, officials said.
Police have not said exactly where in Flagstaff he had been living or what type of work or daily routine he maintained while under the alias. What they did say is that the investigation had never gone cold, even though the original warrant dated back more than two decades.
The arrest shows how older fugitive cases can still move when new information surfaces, especially when different agencies share leads across state lines.
U.S. Marshal says old warrants still deserve active attention
U.S. Marshal Van Bayless of the District of Arizona said the age of the warrant did not lessen its importance. He said cases like this should receive the same attention as newer ones, even when the alleged crime happened years earlier.
Bayless said teams in Texas and Ohio followed the lead to Flagstaff, where the marshal’s task force and Flagstaff police made the arrest. He added that for the people who came forward in 2001, the arrest means the case can finally proceed in court.
His comments underscore the role federal and local agencies played in closing a case that had remained unresolved for a generation.
What the Texas warrant accused Crumpler of in 2001
The warrant out of Lubbock County accused Crumpler of indecency with a child, according to police. Authorities said he fled the Lubbock area after the allegations surfaced in 2001.
No additional details about the underlying allegations were released in the Flagstaff Police announcement. Officials also did not say whether any other charges are expected in Arizona or whether the Texas case will involve additional court steps now that he has been arrested.
For now, the warrant that drove the search remains the central charge tied to the arrest.
How the public can help with the investigation
Flagstaff police are asking anyone with information about the investigation to contact the department at 928-774-1414. Anonymous tips can also be shared with Silent Witness at 928-774-6111.
Investigators did not say whether they are still seeking additional witnesses or whether the public tip lines are tied to the original Texas allegations, the Arizona arrest, or both. The department’s request suggests the case remains open enough for further information to be useful.
As the case moves ahead, authorities are relying on both formal law enforcement cooperation and any new community information that may help fill in remaining gaps.