A family photo of Wendy Hudakoc, who disappeared from Naples, Florida, in 1998

Sister Keeps Searching for Answers Nearly Three Decades After Wendy Hudakoc Vanished From Naples, Florida, as Investigators Still Probe Her Disappearance

NAPLES, FL — Nearly 28 years after Wendy Hudakoc disappeared from her family’s home in Naples, her sister is still searching for answers about what happened that night. Wendy was 14 in November 1998 when she slipped out to attend a party and never returned. Her case remains open with the Collier County Sheriff’s Office, which says investigators have never identified a suspect.

For Wendy’s sister, Sharlene Boyatt, the uncertainty has never faded. She says the family has spent years living with questions, hoping someone who knows what happened will finally speak up. Investigators have reviewed witness accounts, followed leads tied to the party and compared the case with unidentified remains, but no match has brought the family closure.

A normal weekend turned into a disappearance the next morning

Sharlene and Wendy Hudakoc had moved from Canada to Florida with their mother and stepfather and were living in Naples in the late 1990s. Sharlene described the sisters as typical teenagers who spent time with friends and went to the beach. Though they argued like siblings do, she said Wendy was lively, adventurous and not easily scared.

Their parents were out of town the weekend of Nov. 14, 1998, and family friends stayed with the girls because they were still considered too young to be alone. That Saturday night, Wendy planned to go to a friend’s party. She later took a phone call, asked whether Sharlene wanted to go too and then left alone after the answer was no. The next morning, her room was empty and the window was open.

The clues family members noticed after Wendy did not return

Sharlene said she first thought her sister may have stayed somewhere else overnight. But as the hours passed, she began paging Wendy repeatedly using their stepfather’s pager and grew more concerned when there was no response. She eventually called their parents, who were checking out of a hotel on Florida’s east coast, and told them Wendy never came home.

When the parents returned to Naples, they started calling friends and contacting police. Sharlene remembers the early hours as chaotic and emotionally overwhelming. She said she and her mother drove around looking for answers and that, before long, she had an unsettling feeling that she might never see her sister again. That fear has stayed with her for the decades since Wendy vanished.

Friends said Wendy left the party with a man named Ron

As the family tried to reconstruct Wendy’s final hours, they learned that several friends believed she left the party with the same man who had driven her there. Sharlene said Wendy was last seen around 2:30 a.m. on Sunday, Nov. 15, 1998. According to her, the partygoers said the man’s name was Ron.

Family members then gathered mug shots of men in a similar age range who had recently been arrested and showed them to people from the party. Sharlene said the witnesses identified a photo of Ron DePeppo. That name would later become central to the sheriff’s office investigation, though no one has been charged in Wendy’s disappearance and no suspect has been named.

What Collier County investigators say they found

Ralph DiFonzo of the Collier County Sheriff’s Office cold case unit said detectives opened an investigation within 24 hours of Wendy’s disappearance. He said investigators interviewed people who were at the party, along with family members, friends and other possible witnesses. In his view, most of the early work centered on those interviews because investigators did not have a clear search area to focus on.

DiFonzo confirmed that DePeppo was interviewed in 1998. He also said DePeppo’s car caught fire about a week to 10 days after Wendy disappeared, and investigators examined the vehicle afterward but found nothing useful to the case. The sheriff’s office has not recently spoken with DePeppo, and DiFonzo said he is now considered a person of interest rather than a named suspect.

No suspect, no closure and no case resolution yet

Investigators believe Wendy may have been the victim of foul play. DiFonzo said the case was entered into the FBI’s Violent Criminal Apprehension Program, and over the years detectives have compared it with unidentified remains. Those efforts have not produced a match. The sheriff’s office also has familial DNA on file to help with identification if new evidence emerges.

For Sharlene, the pain is tied not only to unanswered questions but also to the milestones Wendy never reached. She has graduated, married and raised children while her sister has remained frozen at age 14 in family memory. Their mother died in 2013, and Sharlene says she wants to know the truth before she dies herself. She also wants Wendy brought home so she can be laid to rest with their mother.

How investigators and the family are still asking for help

The Collier County Sheriff’s Office continues to seek information about Wendy’s disappearance. In 2020, around the 22nd anniversary of the case, the department shared an age-progression image created by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children showing what Wendy might have looked like at 36. If alive today, she would be 42.

At the time she vanished, Wendy was described as 5 feet 6 inches tall, 130 pounds, with light brown hair, hazel eyes, braces, a scar on her left hand and a birthmark on the back of her neck. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at 239-252-9300 or submit an anonymous tip to Southwest Florida Crime Stoppers at 1-800-780-TIPS, or online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *